Children’s Reasoning about Living Kinds

(with Douglas Medin & Sandy Waxman)

This project targets the interaction of cognitve development, culture and experience within the field of folkbiology. The premise is that children of different ages carry already a host of theories and knowledge acquired through different channels and by different means; that these theories differ across culture and across levels of experience; and that these differences are important in the cognitive development of a child.

In particular, the research will explore differences in folkbiological theories as they emerge in a child’s development across different populations. The aim is to show that both culture as well as experiential opportunities are important factors in the cognitive development of children. There is a huge gap in the literature because both, anthropology and psychology evaded this problems for different reasons. While anthropology almost altogether avoided the study of child development, psychology focused on very narrow sets of populations, assuming universal patterns around the globe. Recent research on mental models among adults, however, showed that many of the end products of development – the adult models - are by no means universal. Therefore, this research is crucial for our understanding of (a) cognitive development in general, (b) the emergence and effect of cultural knowledge. These issues are even more important as children from different cultural backgrounds increasingly attend our schools.

Proven methods are used to assess the folkbiological concepts of children of different ages across cultures. It is important to note, that not one single task provides the data on which our results will rely, but that an array of tasks are employed to understand (and confirm) the individual findings. The proposed methods have already been tested among the target populations: Native American and rural Majority Culture children of central Wisconsin urban Majority Culture children and indigenous children in Mexico (Maya speakers in Yucatán). This particular selection of the study populations not only dramatically expands our database on child development, but furthermore allows us to exam cultural differences across groups living in the same environment (Native Americans and Majority Culture of rural Wisconsin) as well as to explore the impact of different environments across members of one culture (rural vs. urban).

Applied tasks include (1) name generation; (2) reasoning tasks (3) Parent – child speech dyads and (4) ethnographic description of classroom and curricula content. These studies are important to: (1) establish a first approximation to a more concise theory of the development of folkbiological models; (2) to enhance our understanding of the formation and transformation of cultural knowledge; (3) to assess the role culture and the environment plays in elaborating these models and (4) in assessing the role of culture and expertise in cognitive development.

This research is supported by the NIH and NSF.

Publications related to the Project:

 

Waxman, S.; Medin, D. & Ross, N. (in press).”Folkbiological Reasoning from a cross-cultural developmental perspective: Early essentialist notions are shaped by  cultural beliefs. Developmental Psychology.

 

Ross, N.; Medin, D.; Coley, J. & Atran, S. (2003.). “Cultural and Experiential Differences in the Development of Folkbiological Induction.”

Cognitive Development, Vol.18:25-47.

Atran,S.; Medin, D. & Ross, N. (in press.).”Evolution and Devolution of Knowledge: A Tale of two biologies.” Journal of the Royal Anthropological

Society.

 

 


Back